the artroom
3.3

Return with a difference

Clarify, extend and regenerate

Systematically clarify ideas using drawing informed by established painting practice

The brief

What happens when I return to an earlier idea with a new question?

Use a related sequence of drawing and painting to clarify a personal idea, extend it and explore regeneration. Start with your own previous artwork or a new initial investigation. Treat the sequence as a thinking process, in which evaluation leads to changes in subsequent work.

Materials & preparation

Your own earlier studies, fresh observed sources where needed, drawing and painting materials selected for the inquiry, and a way to record the sequence and decisions.

Use your own drawings and photographs as starting points. Record sources and seek permission for people, places and culturally significant material. Discuss tikanga and context with your teacher where relevant.

Suggested size & quantity

Use these ranges to plan your studio time and materials with your teacher. They are classroom suggestions, not NZQA minimums, maximums or grade requirements. Adapt them to your idea, working pace and access needs.

Developing sequence

Aim for about 10–14 new related drawings or paintings: 4–6 A6–A5 investigations to clarify the issue, 4–5 A4 developments to extend it, and 2–3 A4–A3 works that revisit and re-form an earlier idea. This is one possible teaching route; the grade guide explains the different assessment expectations.

Workbook

Allow about 10–12 A3 pages, or 20–24 A4 pages, including the new sequence, brief evaluations and references to earlier work. Include a clear photograph of any earlier artwork needed to understand the return; it does not count as a new work in this suggested range.

Choosing the next work

Keep the sequence responsive to discoveries. A return may require several small trials rather than one large painting. Agree any changes to the suggested number and scale with your teacher, keeping the relationship between earlier and later ideas visible.

One workbook page means one side of a sheet; a two-page spread counts as two pages. A3 is 297 × 420 mm, A4 is 210 × 297 mm, A5 is 148 × 210 mm and A6 is 105 × 148 mm. Two A4 pages offer about the same area as one A3 page for planning; this does not change any external submission format. Mount small studies or use clear photographs of separate works rather than making everything twice.

Artist connections

Choose the connections that serve your intention. The contemporary models offer different approaches; select a relevant comparison rather than studying every artist. These works are references, not assessment exemplars.

Use the models to investigate revisiting, re-forming and revealing earlier decisions. Make a new direction grow from your own previous work and evaluate what changed.

  • Shane Cotton

    Contemporary Māori · Aotearoa New Zealand

    Cotton reworks historical references to investigate bicultural identity and colonisation. Compare how recurring forms change meaning through placement, scale and surrounding space, while keeping their particular cultural histories in view.

    Gow Langsford · artist profile and paintings · Painting investigation

  • Séraphine Pick

    Contemporary · Aotearoa New Zealand

    Pick’s atmospheric painting investigates memory, the body and states of consciousness. Compare how layered figures, shifts in colour and uncertain spaces can connect an external scene with an internal experience.

    The Arts Foundation Te Tumu Toi · artist profile · Painting investigation

  • Mark Bradford

    Contemporary · United States

    Bradford’s building-up and removal of paper connects material process with the social life of a city. Read his account of collage and décollage, then ask how adding and removing can each generate an idea.

    Art21 · artist interview on process and materials · Painting investigation

  • Frances Hodgkins

    Aotearoa New Zealand / Britain

    Look at how still-life objects and landscape can share a painted space. Try shifting the relationship between an object, its surroundings and its colour.

    Christchurch Art Gallery · Still Life

Historical comparison

Frances Hodgkins painting of a vase of pink flowers, vessels and fruit set against a loosely painted landscape.
Frances Hodgkins Still Life in a Landscape, c. 1928The MFAT Collection. Source: New Zealand Parliament. No known copyright restrictions. Image source & rights

Artwork reproduction rights and assessment permission are different. A reusable image on this site is not automatically suitable for your assessed portfolio. Read the external conditions.

Studio sequence

Use this as a flexible route through the learning. Let the work suggest the next move.

  1. Locate a live problem

    Review your own work and identify an unresolved pictorial or conceptual issue. Choose established painting practices that can help you investigate it. Frame a question that can be answered through further drawing.

  2. Clarify in sequence

    Make related drawings that analyse and adjust the issue. Use each result to decide the next step. Keep the relationship between the works legible.

  3. Critically extend

    Evaluate which decisions are productive and pursue an implication of them. Change the relationship between form and idea, rather than adding a new effect without a reason.

  4. Revisit and regenerate

    Return to an earlier drawing or idea. Re-form it using discoveries from later work to create a new direction. Maintain the conceptual connection while testing a different visual possibility.

  5. Trace the thinking

    Order the drawings to show progression. Identify where clarification, extension or regeneration actually happens. Retain brief evaluations, but allow the visual sequence to carry the main evidence.

A useful studio conversation

Put two related works side by side. Describe what changed, show the evidence and explain what you will investigate next. Invite feedback, then make your own decision.

Evidence checklist

Use this to review your work. Completing the list does not guarantee a grade.

0 of 3 evidence checks complete

Presentation & submission

Your teacher will confirm the assessment window, support available, final evidence and local authenticity procedures. This sheet is an original teaching resource; it is not an NZQA-issued assessment. Compare NZQA’s annotated exemplars.

What changes between grades?

Student-friendly guidance adapted from the standard. The whole body of relevant evidence determines the grade; the examples below illustrate possibilities.

Grade distinctions for AS91451
GradeWhat the evidence needs to show
AchievementClarify an idea systematically through analysis, reflection and further drawing.In this task: Each connected work helps resolve or sharpen the initial issue.
MeritExtend the idea through critical evaluation and further development.In this task: The sequence pursues a new implication of an earlier discovery.
ExcellenceRegenerate through critically revisiting and reforming ideas from your own earlier work.In this task: A return produces a new direction that extends the inquiry rather than restyling an image.

Authority: NZQA AS91451 achievement criteria and explanatory notes (PDF).

Watch for

A sudden unrelated new subject is not necessarily regeneration; make the relationship to the previous idea visible.

Pause & reflect

Identify the return point. What did you know at that moment that you did not know when you made the original work?

These optional working notes belong to you. This website does not submit assessment evidence.

Notes and checkboxes can be saved in this browser. On a shared device, clear them before leaving.

Teacher notes

Teacher access

Enter the teacher password to open teaching notes and lesson plans.

NZQA sources for this sheet

Checked 22 November 2026. This original task sheet interprets NZQA requirements for a painting classroom; official NZQA documents govern assessment.